Tagset Cleanup Suggestion Post

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Tagset Here

If you find duplicate or incorrect tags, please post them here! Or e-mail us at hurtcomfortexmod@gmail.com

Previous comments on other posts are fine! They do not need to be reposted. Please try to keep new tagset cleanup posts on this one or e-mail going forward, so we can keep track of them more easily.

Mods will be going through the tagset themselves so alerting us is entirely optional! We just appreciate any help people would like to provide.

Examples of tags to bring to our attention.

Duplicate Relationships!

Jack Frost/Punxsutawney Phil (hurt Phil)
Jack Frost/Punxsutawney Phil (hurt Punxsutawney)
Punxsutawney Phil/Jack Frost ((hurt Phil))

Relationships under the wrong fandom!

"Jack Frost/Punxsutawney Phil (hurt Phil) is under MCU when it should be under Mythology"

Misspellings!

Jack Forst/Punxsutawney Phil (hurt Phil)
"Charecter has borken brones"

Duplicate Freeforms!

"Broken Toe"
"Fractured Toe"
"Toe has been Broken"

Tagset Here

Comments

[fencesit]

Lan Wangji/ Wei Wuxian (hurt LWJ) is a dupe of Lan Wangji/Wei Wuxian (hurt LWJ) in The Untamed (TV)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[lovelit]

Found a duplicate tag!

憂国のモリアーティ | Yuukoku no Moriarty | Moriarty the Patriot (Manga)
Sherlock Holmes/William James Moriarty (hurt William)
Sherlock Holmes/William James Moriarty (Yuukoku no Moriarty) (hurt William)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[rubylily]

I found some typos under Fire Emblem: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem: Three Houses: MalebByleth/Claude von Riegan (hurt Both) and MalebByleth/Claude von Riegan (hurt Byleth) should be "Male Byleth/Claude von Riegan (hurt Both)" and "Male Byleth/Claude von Riegan (hurt Byleth)".

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[sholio]

Duplicate in MCU:

Peter Parker/Tony Stark (hurt Tony) (Marvel Cinematic Universe)
Peter Parker/Tony Stark (hurt Tony) (MCU)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you! Duplicates have been rounded up and the Peter Parker and Tony Stark related tags have been moved to Iron Man (movies)

[sirvalkyrie]

Peter Parker wasn't in the Iron Man movies.

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Word of God says he was the kid in the mask Iron Man saves in Iron Man 2, and as otherwise the next movie they're both in is Captain America Civil War, Iron Man fits better.

[sirvalkyrie]

What about putting them under the Spider-Man movies? Both have a significant role in Homecoming, which also highlights their relationship?

[nothfan23]

A couple of similar tags

The aftermath of sex pollen
Aftermath of sex pollen

careful sex because one partner is ill or injured
Careful Sex Because One Partner Is Injured/Ill

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[sholio]

Misspellings:

Emotional Disress after an Assassination Attempt (should be "Distress")
helping and injured person dress (should be "an")


Some duplicates:

Robot - Destroying Robot/Cyborg/AI's Mechanical Parts
Robots - Destroying Robot/Cyborg/AI's Mechanical Parts

Torture - Tortured While Loved Ones Were Forced To Watch
Torture - while loved ones are forced to watch


And these may be similar enough to merge?

Mistakenly Believes the Other is Dead
Thought other character was dead
Presumed Dead

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

We decided with the
Mistakenly Believes the Other is Dead
Thought other character was dead
Presumed Dead

The first two are duplicates, the third seems unique. Presumed Dead could be that they're missing, presumed dead, but the other character(s) could still believe they're alive.

[sholio]

That makes sense to me!

[gothyringwald]

Duplicate in Supernatural:

Benny Lafitte/Dean Winchester (Dean hurt)
Benny Lafitte/Dean Winchester (hurt Dean)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

The ship nominations I emailed aren't listed. Is that on purpose?

[hurtcomfortexmod]

There is no need to worry, that's entirely just that they're on the known to-do list and haven't been gotten to yet. There will not be forgotten.

[mahmfic]

Ah okay. 🥰

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate in Star Trek AOS:

James T. Kirk/Spock (hurt Jim)
James T. Kirk/Spock (hurt Kirk)


Misspelling in Star Trek Discovery (should be Philippa)

Mirror Phillippa Georgiou/Nhan (hurt Georgiou)


Also, these are under Star Trek Picard, but Geordi doesn't appear in that so I think they'd fit better under Next Generation?

Hugh | Third of Five/Geordi La Forge (hurt Geordi)
Hugh | Third of Five/Geordi La Forge (hurt Hugh)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

I went through the freeforms!

Misspellings:

Character caught in moral dillemma
Comforting someone who is dealing with grief and loss and has shut theymselves off from everyone
Emotional Disress after an Assassination Attempt
New bed-wetting because of trauma and comfort associated w it
Time Loop - Hurt character is stuck in the loop and comforter must get them out of i

Odd phrasing:

Coping through past rape through sex
Refuse to Leave Other Character's Side
Time traveler can't complete preemptive murder; realizes enemy went evil due to lack comfort

(I'd go with "Coping with", "Refusing", "lack of comfort")


It looks like the arrow in these doesn't show up right on AO3? (I only actually figured out it was an arrow by previewing here, on AO3 it shows up as - & g t ; but without the spaces):

Fights with family member -> Helps them feel better in some shape or form
Lost someone in a zombie apocalypse -> Makes them feel better somehow
Nauseous from being rejected -> Isn't ready for a relationship and wants to let them know
Nervous about confessing love -> Misunderstands and thinks it's for someone else
One Character is Afraid of Ghosts -> The Other character is helping them through it


(Potential) Duplicates:

[Blank] to Lovers - Casual/Unromantic Sex Leads to Unwanted Feelings
Casual/Unromantic Sex Leads to Unwanted Feelings

Character A Comforted By Character B In Dreams
Comfort offered in a dream sequence

Character A drapes their jacket over B's shoulders
Comforter drapes their coat over hurt character's shoulders

Caring for hurt character by cooking for them or getting them their favourite food
Cooking for someone as comfort

helping and injured person dress
Helping hurt character to dress/undress

Insomnia
Insomnia and Sleep Deprivation

Morning Sickness
Pregnancy: morning sickness

Character being protected isn't used to being cared about
Protectiveness - Character being protected isn't used to being cared about

Technically awful attempts at comfort are actually very comforting
technically awful attempts at comforting are actually very comforting

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you! The only one I'm still pondering is

Character A drapes their jacket over B's shoulders
Comforter drapes their coat over hurt character's shoulders

On one hand they're very close, but the first one leaves it open for "hurt character tries to comfort the comforter" situations. The rest have been fixed.

[(Anonymous)]

I nominated "Character A drapes their jacket over B's shoulders", and my intention was indeed for it to be open for interpretation. So I'd very much like for it to stay the way I nominated it, if possible!

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Then it shall stay.

[(Anonymous)]

AYRT

Yay, thank you!

[elsajeni]

Not exactly misspelled, but a stray space:
Kira Nerys /Odo (hurt Kira)
in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you!

[ruuger]

All the pairings under Doctor Who belong under Doctor Who 2005 (assuming that you want to separate classic and new Who - if not, then you should move everything from under DW 2005 and DW 1963 under the generic Doctor Who instead)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you! They've been put in Doctor Who 2005.

[(Anonymous)]

Misspellings under Lost:

Kate Austen/Jack Shepahrd (hurt Jack)
Kate Austen/Jack Shepard (both hurt)

Jack's last name is spelled Shephard.

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you! They have been corrected.

[skatzaa]

Hi! Sorry if this is too late; I know that sometimes after signups open mods can't make any further changes to the tagset.

However, the tag "Kix & Any 501st Member (hurt Kix)" seems to have gone wandering somewhere and I can't find it. It's been approved on my noms page (https://archiveofourown.org/tag_sets/5442/nominations/186534 if that's any help) under SW: TCW, but it's not in any of the SW fandoms that I looked through.

If there's nothing that can be done at that point, that's totally fine, but I wanted to check in about it before I started on my signup. Thank you! :-)

[hurtcomfortexmod]

We don't allow Any relationship tags, but sometimes tag mods make errors. If you would like to suggest a replacement such as "Kix & 501st (hurt Kix)" which is group and can include any and all, or Kix & specific 501st members we can edit them in now.

[skatzaa]

Gotcha, sorry for the mistake then! "Kix & 501st (hurt Kix)" would be absolutely lovely if you can <3 thank you!!

[hurtcomfortexmod]

It has been added for you!

[zaniida]

Hey, shouldn't Clint Barton & Loki be under the Thor fandom instead of under Avengers? They both showed up first in Thor, even if they didn't directly interact until Avengers.

Cannot vs. Can Not

[zaniida]

Character A can not be rescued from their situation so Character B helps them endure it

--this should be "cannot" ("cannot" is a full negative, while "can not" implies possibilities: could be not rescued, could be rescued).

Character is frustrated by need for help with every day tasks

--should be "everyday" ("everyday" means commonplace things we do on a regular basis; "every day tasks" would mean something like "all the tasks done during daytime").

Neither comforter or comfortee will directly acknowledge that comforting is taking place

--less important, but that "or" should be "nor" (the basic construction is neither/nor)

Re: Cannot vs. Can Not

[hurtcomfortexmod]

Thank you so much for the help, sadly once signups are open and the tagset is in use, corrections can't be made anymore without breaking the signup page.

Re: Cannot vs. Can Not

[(Anonymous)]

Ah, I had wondered. Ah well.